September in the West Philippine Sea: A Rammed Fisheries Ship and a Blocked Resupply to Ayungin
news27-09-2026

Two months after a rough July, the West Philippine Sea produced two more serious incidents in a single week of September 2026. On Friday, September 18, the Philippine Coast Guard (PCG) said a China Coast Guard ship deliberately rammed a Philippine fisheries vessel that was delivering fuel to Filipino fishermen off Palawan. On Thursday, September 24, Philippine authorities said Chinese navy and coast guard ships blocked a resupply mission to the BRP Sierra Madre at Second Thomas (Ayungin) Shoal, the first publicly known obstruction of such a mission since 2024.
Nobody was hurt in either incident. Both sides tell very different stories about who caused what.
For the July background (a baton strike at Ayungin and water cannon at Scarborough), see A Rough Week in the West Philippine Sea. This post covers what each side says happened in September, and what it means for fishing communities, city consumers, and foreigners living here.
September 18: A Fisheries Vessel Rammed Off Palawan
The ship involved was the BRP Datu Magat Salamat, a vessel of the Bureau of Fisheries and Aquatic Resources (BFAR). According to the Philippine Star, it was delivering fuel subsidies and food packs to Filipino fishermen in the Kalayaan Island Group after weeks of monsoon rains.
According to the PCG and the National Task Force for the West Philippine Sea (NTF-WPS), as reported by the Inquirer and GMA News:
- At about 11:04 a.m., China Coast Guard vessel CCG-21585 cut across the BFAR ship’s stern at roughly 10 meters.
- At about 11:13 a.m., it struck the BFAR ship’s starboard side, then passed astern at about five meters.
- The impact bent or broke railings, deformed metal stanchions and support structures, and scattered deck fixtures and equipment.
- No injuries were reported.
- The NTF-WPS placed the collision about 6.36 nautical miles north-northwest of Abad Santos Shoal, roughly 54 nautical miles (about 100 km) off Palawan, inside the Philippine exclusive economic zone. Reuters described the area as near Sabina Shoal.
PCG spokesperson Rear Adm. Jay Tarriela called it “an intentional ramming,” not a collision, and said it violated international collision rules. The NTF-WPS called on China to “cease dangerous and unlawful actions that endanger lives at sea.” The Department of Foreign Affairs urged China to avoid escalation, and U.S. Ambassador Lee Lipton condemned the ramming.
One detail shows how stretched these missions are. A day earlier, the same BFAR ship had run aground at Hasa-Hasa Shoal while approaching fishing boats, and had to be pulled free by the PCG’s BRP Malabrigo. After the ramming, it was sent to Coron for a seaworthiness check.
China’s account is different. According to Reuters and Al Jazeera, the China Coast Guard said it was conducting law enforcement near the shoal, and that the Philippine vessel ignored repeated warnings, changed course and sped up to cross the Chinese ship’s bow. China blamed the Philippine side for the collision and said its crew acted professionally. The Chinese Embassy also criticized the U.S. Embassy for its statement.
September 24: The Ayungin Resupply That Didn’t Happen
Second Thomas Shoal, called Ayungin in the Philippines and Ren’ai Jiao in China, is where a small Philippine detachment lives aboard the BRP Sierra Madre, a World War II-era ship deliberately grounded on the reef in 1999. It needs regular rotation and resupply (RORE) runs for food, water and fresh personnel.
Since a provisional arrangement between Manila and Beijing in July 2024, those runs had gone smoothly. Bloomberg, via gCaptain, reported that a Philippine official said in August that 15 missions had been completed without incident.
According to Philippine officials, as reported by the Inquirer, the Daily Tribune, USNI News and Maritime Executive:
- The convoy was the resupply boat M/V Lapu-Lapu with three Philippine Navy and PCG support vessels, including the PCG’s BRP Malabrigo and BRP Cabra.
- The AFP said three People’s Liberation Army Navy warships and five China Coast Guard vessels were involved. The AFP spokesman said the Chinese ships began tailing the convoy about 60 nautical miles from the shoal.
- The PCG said a PLA Navy warship issued a radio warning of “compulsory measures,” after which a China Coast Guard ship maneuvered against the Lapu-Lapu in a way that threatened a collision. Tarriela said the ships “ganged up” on an unarmed supply boat at night.
- The mission was called off. The Inquirer reported a Philippine Navy vessel also had a mechanical problem, which contributed to the decision to turn back.
- No injuries were reported.
The task force said Chinese forces “put Filipino personnel at risk and obstructed a legitimate humanitarian and sustainment operation.” On September 27, Ambassador Lipton denounced the “dangerous blocking and other irresponsible maneuvers.”
China’s position: China Coast Guard spokesperson Jiang Lue said, via Xinhua, that the Philippines sent a ship to supply “an illegally grounded Philippine vessel” despite China’s objections, that the coast guard monitored it and gave loudspeaker warnings, and that its measures were lawful. He urged the Philippines to “immediately stop all acts of provocation and trouble-making.” China’s Global Times, citing a source, said Beijing had not approved this mission in advance and that the Philippine ship withdrew without a serious confrontation.
That last point is the heart of the disagreement. Chinese commentators quoted by the Global Times say the 2024 arrangement means resupply proceeds with Chinese permission. Manila says the shoal is inside its EEZ, that it needs no permission, and that the arrangement does not require Beijing’s approval. The text of the arrangement has never been published, so outsiders can’t settle it.
Why It Matters
Two things stand out about September:
- Fuel missions keep getting caught up in it. In July, it was water cannon during fuel handouts near Scarborough. In September, it was a ramming during a fuel handout off Palawan. These missions exist because fuel is expensive this year (see The Global Oil Shock Hits Home), and fishermen need the diesel to reach their grounds.
- The Ayungin truce has frayed. For two years, the resupply arrangement was one of the few things both sides pointed to as working. Whether September 24 is a one-off or a new pattern will depend on the next mission.
Cities vs. Provinces
In the Cities
For most people in Metro Manila, Cebu or Davao, this is news, not daily life.
- Fish prices in city markets depend on many fishing grounds, the weather, the season and fuel costs. A single incident offshore does not change the price of galunggong the next morning.
- The bigger effect is on mood and politics. Videos from the PCG spread quickly on social media, and the West Philippine Sea is a reliable topic in Senate hearings.
- Nothing about city life, flights or ferries was disrupted.
In the Provinces
For fishing towns in Palawan, including the Kalayaan Island Group, and in Zambales and Pangasinan facing Scarborough, it is personal.
- The BFAR fuel and food deliveries are a real part of household income in a year of high diesel prices. When a mission is disrupted, the fuel doesn’t arrive.
- Monsoon weather had already kept boats in port for weeks before the September 18 mission, according to the Philippine Star.
- Fishermen who go farther out spend more on diesel, ice and food per trip, and many say they are shadowed or driven off when they do. Local fish supply in these towns depends far more on what happens offshore than national markets do.
- For the families of the Navy and Marine personnel on the Sierra Madre, a cancelled resupply means a delayed rotation home.
What It Means for Expats
As with July, these incidents are not a reason to panic, and day-to-day life is unaffected.
- Daily life continues. Palawan, including El Nido, Coron and Puerto Princesa, is open as usual. The incidents happened dozens of nautical miles offshore.
- Stay away from contested features. Tourist trips stay close to shore. Don’t charter a boat toward Ayungin, Sabina, Scarborough or other disputed shoals, and don’t fly drones over coast guard or naval vessels.
- Read both sides. The PCG, AFP and NTF-WPS post quickly; Reuters, AP and the major Philippine outlets usually add China’s response within a day. A dramatic clip without context is not the whole story.
- Keep your opinions low-key. Filipinos feel strongly about this. As a visa holder, avoid rallies and online arguments.
- Register with your embassy. It is free, and it means your government can reach you if anything changes.
- Watch prices, not headlines. For most expats, the practical impact of the dispute shows up in fuel and food prices, not in security.
Summary
- September 18: The PCG said China Coast Guard vessel CCG-21585 deliberately rammed the BFAR ship BRP Datu Magat Salamat about 54 nautical miles off Palawan during a fuel-subsidy mission for fishermen. No injuries. China says the Philippine ship cut across its bow and caused the collision.
- September 24: Philippine officials said three PLA Navy warships and five China Coast Guard ships shadowed and blocked a resupply convoy to the BRP Sierra Madre at Ayungin Shoal, starting about 60 nautical miles out. The mission was called off. No injuries. China says it lawfully monitored and warned a mission it had not approved.
- It was the first publicly known obstruction of an Ayungin resupply since the July 2024 provisional arrangement, which the two sides now interpret differently.
- The people most affected are fishing communities in Palawan, Zambales and Pangasinan and the personnel on the Sierra Madre. For city residents and expats, the effects are indirect.
Sources
- GMA News: NTF-WPS condemns China’s ramming of BFAR vessel off Palawan
- Inquirer: PCG: China Coast Guard ship rams BFAR vessel off Palawan
- Al Jazeera: Chinese ship rams Philippines gov’t vessel in South China Sea: Coastguard
- Philippine Star: BFAR vessel hit by China Coast Guard ship
- Interaksyon (Reuters): China vessel rams Philippine boat on refueling mission, coast guard says
- Interaksyon (Reuters): Philippines accuses China of obstructing resupply mission in South China Sea
- USNI News: Chinese Cutters, Warships Block Philippine Resupply Mission to Second Thomas Shoal
- Maritime Executive: New Standoff Between China and Philippines Near Second Thomas Shoal
- Inquirer: China asserting position in WPS after latest interference, Tarriela
- CGTN: China urges Philippines to stop provocations in South China Sea
- Global Times: China Coast Guard thwarts Philippine illegal resupply attempt around Ren’ai Jiao: source
- Daily Tribune: US condemns China’s interference in Ayungin resupply mission
- gCaptain (Bloomberg): Philippines says China blocked sea mission, first since 2024
Thinking of Moving to the Philippines? Get Reliable Guidance
Online communities are helpful for general questions. For anything important, you still need accurate, professional, and updated information. E636 Expat Services helps foreigners with:
- Residency and long term visas
- Bank account opening
- Health insurance guidance
- Real estate assistance
- Business setup
- Retirement planning
- A smooth and secure transition into life in the Philippines
If you want to move with confidence instead of relying on random comments online, we can guide you every step of the way.
Book a consultation with E636 and start your journey the right way.
Image credits (via Unsplash, free under the Unsplash License):
- Top image: “a couple of men in a boat” by Josephus Bajo


